|
Sectoral Development Strategies
| Sectoral development refers to strategies that expand the number
or quality of jobs in a particular economic sector. These strategic interventions
within an industry are designed to improve that sector's competitiveness,
expand the number of jobs within the sector, or affect its supply of workers.
All of these results can have a positive impact on low-income communities. |
As the name implies, sectoral strategies focus on a particular economic
sector. A sector is commonly defined as a group of firms which share some
common characteristics. The characteristics might be a product (e.g., socks
and hosiery), a market (hardware stores) a technology (metal working equipment),
a resource (wood), or even a workforce need (electronic technicians). The
most common usage of the term is to describe a group of firms with a common
product.
Whatever the commonality, an organization can devise an intervention
strategy based upon the specific barriers and opportunities relevant to
the targeted businesses. By working intensively with a group of employers
who share common issues, an organization can develop deeper relations with
targeted firms and work collaboratively with them to advance common goals.
A sectoral strategy or project encompasses the following attributes:
-
A clearly defined "sector" that is explicitly targeted;
-
A clear vision and goals established from the outset of the project;
-
An understanding of the dynamics of the targeted sector; and
-
A comprehensive approach that seeks to create systematic change within
a sector by changing institutional relationships among businesses, between
business and labor, and among business, government and training providers.30
What Makes a Sectoral Strategy?
Sectoral strategies have several special attributes:
-
Sectoral strategies can either create jobs (sectoral economic development)
or help disadvantaged persons find jobs (sectoral employment development).
Creating jobs is sometimes called "working on the demand side of the labor
market," while training workers and helping them obtain jobs is called
"working on the supply side of the labor market."
-
Organizations can develop specialized competencies with which to add value.
Instead of being "all things to all people," sectoral strategies develop
specialized knowledge about employer or business needs and figure out ways
to fill those needs in the best interest of their members or constituents.
-
By focusing on a sector, organizations can develop enduring relationships
with employers and other elements of their support infrastructure (e.g.,
community colleges and skills training programs). These relationships can
help the organization achieve systemic change in the ways firms recruit,
hire and train workers.
Supporting
Sectoral Strategies
Funders can support sectoral projects in at least four ways:
-
Fund a nonprofit organization to initiate and manage a sectoral economic
development (job creation) project;
-
Fund a nonprofit organization to initiate and manage a sectoral employment
development (job access) project;
-
Fund a nonprofit organization to advocate for policy changes in existing
sectoral economic or employment development projects managed by units of
government, civic associations or business organizations;
-
Fund a nonprofit organization to undertake complementary, neighborhood-based
employment development or economic development activities which will "piggy-back"
onto an existing sectoral program.
The rest of this chapter will explore sectoral economic development (job
creation) strategies and sectoral employment development strategies (job
access), as well as programs which combine both approaches.
Sectoral Economic Development Strategies
Sectoral economic development programs originated in the early 1980s, when
states and localities began experimenting with economic development strategies
targeted to key industries or sectors of their economy. Several early examples
in Massachusetts - the Needle Trades Action Project, the Machine Trades
Action Project and the Massachusetts Metalworking Partnership - were created
to revive and strengthen that state's mature industries. Similarly, the
city of Chicago was an early pioneer of sectoral approaches for local governments,
creating task forces and action programs targeted to several key manufacturing
sectors, including the steelmaking industry.
The distinguishing feature of these sectoral efforts is that they started
with an analysis of the local economy, identified key sectors, and organized
programs around those sectors. Programs or services were tailored from
this analysis. Typically, the range of programs included:
-
Organizing and promoting cooperation among firms in the sector;
-
Researching and developing new technology or new products;
-
Transferring or modernizing technology to assist firms in adopting up-to-date
technology;
-
Developing specialized financing to fill capital needs not met by banks
and other conventional financing sources;
-
Creating employment and training programs to assure an adequate and skilled
workforce;
-
Setting up marketing programs to help firms access new markets and generate
more sales; and
-
Addressing other key competitiveness issues revealed by the industry analysis.
Examples include transportation, zoning or land use impediments, or the
cost of energy.
These programs and services are not new. The sectoral approach adds value
by custom-fitting services to the needs of a particular sector and a particular
set of employers.
30 Beth Siegel and Peter Kwass.
Jobs
and the Urban Poor: Publicly Initiated Sectoral Strategies. Sommervile,
MA: Mount Auburn Associates. 1995, p. 3.
|